Host An Unforgettable Book Club

Book Selection, Ideas, Food for Thought,
and More!

Follow Buttery Books on Facebook
Follow Buttery Books on Twitter
Follow Buttery Books on RSS Feed

Print this post Print this post    Email This Post Email This Post

The Truth According to Us by Annie Barrows

The Truth According to Us by Annie Barrows is a wonderful novel which centers on the once-prominent Romeyn family, a pack of quirky, engaging characters with 12-year old Willa at its center.    Book clubs will will have so much fun discussing  this novel and its interesting cast.  (Felix was my second favorite character – how’s that for raising few eyebrows?)

The_Truth_According_to_Us_by_Annie_Barrows From the Publisher:
Annie Barrows once again evokes the charm and eccentricity of a small town filled with extraordinary characters. Her new novel, The Truth According to Us, brings to life an inquisitive young girl, her beloved aunt, and the alluring visitor who changes the course of their destiny forever.
In the summer of 1938, Layla Beck’s father, a United States senator, cuts off her allowance and demands that she find employment on the Federal Writers’ Project, a New Deal jobs program. Within days, Layla finds herself far from her accustomed social whirl, assigned to cover the history of the remote mill town of Macedonia, West Virginia, and destined, in her opinion, to go completely mad with boredom.
Read more . . .

But once she secures a room in the home of the unconventional Romeyn family, she is drawn into their complex world and soon discovers that the truth of the town is entangled in the thorny past of the Romeyn dynasty.
At the Romeyn house, twelve-year-old Willa is desperate to learn everything in her quest to acquire her favorite virtues of ferocity and devotion—a search that leads her into a thicket of mysteries, including the questionable business that occupies her charismatic father and the reason her adored aunt Jottie remains unmarried. Layla’s arrival strikes a match to the family veneer, bringing to light buried secrets that will tell a new tale about the Romeyns. As Willa peels back the layers of her family’s past, and Layla delves deeper into town legend, everyone involved is transformed—and their personal histories completely rewritten.
The Dial Press; First Edition / First Printing edition (June 9, 2015)

Purchase The Truth According to Us

Purchase Amazon Purchase Kindle Books Purchase IndieBound Purchase Audible

Book Club Preparation


Goodreads: 3.8 stars (7,761 ratings)
Amazon: 4.2 stars (352 ratings)
LibraryThing: 3.9 stars (143 ratings)
My Rating: 4 stars

Discussion Questions

Spoiler Alert: Discussion guide may contain spoilers to the book.

1. Early in the novel, Willa resolves to acquire the virtues of “ferocity and devotion.” Do you concur that these are, actually, virtues? Which of the characters in The Truth According to Us possesses them? Do you know anyone who does?
2. Much of the story revolves around events that occurred when Jottie, Felix, Vause, and Sol were children and teenagers. Do you think the author believes that character is essentially unchanging from childhood to adulthood? Do you agree? Have you changed in essence from your childhood self?
3. The Truth According to Us is set in a small town where everyone seems to know everyone else. Have you ever lived in a situation like that? Would you find living in Macedonia appealing or stifling? With our multiple forms of instantaneous communication, it could be said that the entire world has become a small town. Do you agree? Do you think we live in a more or less anonymous world now? Read more . . .

4. Felix Romeyn is undoubtedly a flawed character. Sol McKubin is, by most standards, a far more honorable person. And yet Jottie speaks of “ . . . her growing certainty that if Sol had been in Felix’s place, he would, after a time, have come to believe that what he told her was the truth.” Do you agree? If so, which man is more honorable?
5. Of all the characters, Layla Beck may be the one that changes the most. In her final letter to her father, she says that she’s learned that “ignoring the past is the act of a fool.” What is she referring to? Discuss how the lessons she’s learned are revealed in the differences between her relationship with Felix and that with Emmett.
6. While The Truth According to Us is not an epistolary novel, there are many letters from Layla’s various correspondences woven throughout the narrative. How did these letters contribute to your understanding of her character, and to the story as a whole? Were there any letters that really stand out in your memory? Why do you think that is?
7. Is Felix a good father?
8. Author Annie Barrows has said, with regard to setting her novel in 1938, “The second world war looms so large in our perception of our individual selves—and even larger in our perception of America’s identity—that it takes a massive feat of imagination to remove it, or block it out, even very temporarily. To catch a glimpse of a small town in America, not ‘before the War,’ or even ‘before people realized War was inevitable,’ but without the inevitability—well, it’s nearly impossible.” Discuss the historical events that have marked your time. Do you think that we, like the characters in The Truth According to Us, are facing a major pivot point in our national identity? What do you predict it to be?
9. At one point, Willa’s Uncle Emmett advises her “Don’t ask questions if you’re not going to like the answers.” He clarifies that she should ask herself whether the answer could endanger something that’s precious to her, and if so, refrain from asking. Willa ignores his advice entirely, but would it have been better—for her and everyone else—if she had taken it? Have you ever regretted your own curiosity?
10. The possibility of knowing the truth about the past is a central preoccupation of The Truth According to Us. Layla says that “if history were defined as only those stories that could be absolutely verified, we’d have no history at all.” Do you agree? Do you think that Layla still believes this at the end of the summer?
11. Of all the characters in The Truth According to Us, who do you most identify with and why?
12. The sisterly bond between Jottie, Mae, and Minerva is intimate and powerful, with Mae and Minerva choosing to live under the same roof during the week, away from their husbands, because “the two of them can’t stand to be apart…they found out they were miserable without each other.” In contrast, the relationship between the two Romeyn brothers is contentious. What do you think of this distinction? How does the presence of strong feminine companionship impact this story? How does this model of loyalty and devotion affect the relationship between young Willa and Bird?
13. The Truth According to Us is broken up into multiple different perspectives, blending young and old voices with epistolary fragments and flashbacks. How do these varied viewpoints contribute to characterization and development in the story? How do they deepen our connection to these characters?
(Discussion Questions from Random House)

The Author

annie_barrows Annie Barrows is a noted author of children’s books and co-author (with her late aunt Mary Ann Shaffer) of the acclaimed best-selling novel The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society.

Annie’s inspirations for The Truth According to Us came from the small towns in West Virginia she visited as a child.   The Truth According to Us is Annie’s “homage to all the storytellers in my family, but especially Mary Ann (Shaffer).”  The Diane Rehm Show

Annie Barrows Website

Food for Thought

Twice a year, Bird and I had to go to Grand Mile to see our mother. We hated those visits. She gripped us too tight and moaned about how we were lost to her. One time I said, “You’re the one who left, aren’t you?” but that only made her moan louder. And she always made Monte Cristo sandwiches for lunch. She called it a treat, but it was the only thing she knew how to make, and Bird usually threw up on the way home. Sometimes, if I held her hand real hard, she didn’t, but mostly she did.  Barrows, Annie. The Truth According to Us: A Novel (p. 167). Random House Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.

Oh my! I love the Monte Cristo sandwiches at Bennigan’s.  Thankfully, I’ve never experienced Bird’s reaction to them.  The recipe below is an appetizer version.

Monte Cristo Sammie Appetizers Recipe


“The Bavarian Restaurant was dim and cool, with fans in the ceiling and white tablecloths and two different kinds of glasses at each place. Father said we could get anything we wanted, and of course Bird tried to get nothing but pie, but I ordered Roast Beef Lafontaine Style, which Father said was a famous Bavarian dish made out of old Frenchmen. I said I knew better than that, and he told Jottie that I was getting too smart and she shouldn’t let me read any more books. He was joking.”Barrows, Annie. The Truth According to Us: A Novel (p. 246-247). Random House Publishing Group. Kindle Edition.

Felix took his sister Jottie and his girls, Willa and Bird, to a Bavarian Restaurant (It was in this scene that I began to think, ‘Maybe Felix isn’t so bad after all.‘). Willa’s dinner choice was a dish I wasn’t familiar with.   I searched my cookbooks and the web but had no luck in finding a Beef Lafontaine recipe.   I ended up using Willa’s description of it in a later passage as “all rolled up with mushrooms on top.”

Roast Beef Lafontaine Style Rolled Up with Mushrooms Recipe


Following dinner, Willa got to order Boston Cream Pie for dessert, even though she couldn’t finish her Roast Beef Lafontaine.

Boston Cream Pie Recipe


Book Club Resources

Recommended Reading

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society was Buttery Books’ first book club selection.

If you loved Willa (my favorite) you’ll love the spunky and curious young heroines in the other three novels below.

Other Notes and Comments

Do you have any other ideas or recipes for a book club party for The Truth According to Us? We would love to have you share them with us! You can leave a comment below and upload pictures as well.

Copyright © 2019 All Rights Reserved.

Looking for Related Information on this Buttery Books Post?

Try Google Search

Custom Search

Author:   Category: book club party ideas  Tags:  

Feel free to add your ideas, comments or book review below.